Sports FAQ
Home / Mixed Martial Arts

So, your P4P list?

Jay2011-03-28 23:18:16 +0000 #1
Well with MMAF's P4P list already out and posted the other day, it's time for Sherpup to take a shot:

Sherpup:

1. GSP.

2. Dancin' Andy

3. Aldo

4. Lil Frankie

5. Fitch

6. Jake Shields

7. Jon Jones

8. Gilly Melendez

9. Shogun

10. Sugar Rashad

MMAF:

1. Dancin' Andy

2. GSP

3. Jon Jones

4. Aldo

5. Dominick Cruz

6. Lil Frankie

7. Maynard

8. Cain Vally

9. Joseph Benavidez

10. Fitch

So.. think they're both bull****? What's your list?
BulldogWrestler2011-03-28 23:32:47 +0000 #2
Mine would look something like this: (just pulled out of my ass)

1) GSP

2) Silva

3) Edgar

4) Aldo (Really a 3B)

5) Melendez

6) Jones

7) Cain Velasquez

8) Dominick Cruz

9) Maynard

10) I dunno, Fitch probably? Maybe Shogun? Junior Dos Santos?
danl082011-03-28 23:29:52 +0000 #3
I don't think a PfP list should go 10 deep. This is trying to show who is the absolute BEST of the best. Thats not a list of ten.

1/2 GSP and A Sliva

3 Jose Aldo

Thats it. Everyone else is somewhere below these guys at this point in time. Maybe Cain makes the list when he gets back. maybe JDS makes the list if he beats Brock and Cain. Maybe Jones makes the list after he beats Rashad and at least 1 or 2 other guys in dominant fashion. I don't really see Edgar as a part of that list yet although I'd like to see him face Aldo.
BulldogWrestler2011-03-28 23:46:41 +0000 #4
I would argue that Edgar deserves to be on the list more than Aldo does. He has better wins against more accomplished fighters, his only loss / draw is to another guy who is in the mix. Top that off with the fact that he's fighting a weight class above what he would be fighting at (due to there being no money at 145 when he started) and I think he's definitely in the mix.
Haze2011-03-28 23:37:03 +0000 #5
i like bdw's and my number 10 would almost certainly be JDS..
krazo1012011-03-28 23:50:40 +0000 #6
1. Dancin Andy

2. GSP

3. Aldo

4. Edgar

5. Maynard

6. Jones

7. Cruz

8. Cain

9. Fitch

10. Melendez

Reply

Name:
Content:


Other posts in this category