Sports FAQ
Home / Mixed Martial Arts

UFC Files Suit to Overturn MMA Ban in NYC

Tallica19812011-11-20 01:21:51 +0000 #1


It’s called mixed martial arts for a reason.

The Ultimate Fighting Championship, the sport’s largest promoter, is suing to overturn New York’s ban on live bouts, saying the 1997 law runs roughshod over its freedom of expression, a novel argument that likens MMA to live ballet, music or theater.

Zuffa LLC, which owns the UFC, filed a lawsuit Tuesday in U.S. district court against New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman and Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. seeking a declaration that the ban violates the First Amendment.

Spokesmen for Schneiderman and Vance declined to comment.

The company was joined in the lawsuit by fans of the sport and a group of mixed martial arts fighters — Jon “Bones” Jones, Gina “Conviction” Carano, Frankie “The Answer” Edgar, Matt Hamill (also known as “The Hammer”) and Brian Stann (“All American”) – who “have suffered, and will continue to suffer, irreparable harm” under the ban.

“Live professional MMA is clearly intended and understood as public entertainment and, as such, is expressive activity protected by the First Amendment,” the lawsuit said.

The lawsuit comes as the sport is broadening its audience. In August, Fox Broadcasting Co. and the UFC entered into a seven-year deal that includes four fights a year on broadcast television and will pay the promoter at least $100 million annually. (The first fight aired Saturday, and, according to Fox, drew 5.7 million viewers.) UFC, which hosts its fights inside a chain-link cage dubbed “The Octagon,” holds about 27 live events each year, according to the complaint.

While the arts are protected, no court has ever directly confronted the question of whether athletes have a First Amendment right to be seen in action, said Barry Friedman, a professor at New York University School of Law who is representing the plaintiffs.

“This is the first time to my knowledge that a professional athlete is claiming a First Amendment right to communicate with fans in a live event,” said Friedman.

The courts needn’t declare all sports protected by the First Amendment, because MMA — which, as the name suggests, draws on a mosaic of different fighting styles — is special, Friedman said.

“It’s martial artistry,” he said. “The nature of martial arts is a lot like dancing.”

It is also martial. As in “warlike.”

New York and Connecticut are two states with a ban on live MMA fights. Madison Square Garden and upstate venues have expressed support for hosting the fights, but UFC has been unsuccessful in lobbying the state legislature to overturn the ban, which passed the law about 15 years ago.

If the ban’s purpose is to curb “a message of violence,” the lawsuit said, it “makes no sense” because New Yorkers can watch MMA on television.

But that is no substitute for the real thing, according the complaint.

“As is true of ballet, music, or theater, for an audience, attending a live MMA event is an experience that cannot be replicated on a screen.”

The full complaint is embedded below.

Click the link to view the actual document filed.

BulldogWrestler2011-11-20 01:30:13 +0000 #2
Interesting tactic.

I'm still confused as to why New York and CT are keeping it banned in the first place.
Tallica19812011-11-20 01:54:21 +0000 #3

Originally Posted by BulldogWrestler

Interesting tactic.

I'm still confused as to why New York and CT are keeping it banned in the first place.

NYC is mainly due to pressure from the culinary union.
TheIcon2011-11-20 01:50:01 +0000 #4
I agree. Interesting tactic. Not sure how this will go. My initial reaction is they are reaching but who knows.
fightfan802011-11-20 01:41:34 +0000 #5
The Zuffa legal team leaving no stone unturned...

I think that the Zuffa Union-Labor issues and the Labor lobby in the NY Legislature is the real stumbling block here as others have said.
fightfan802011-11-20 02:07:09 +0000 #6
If this goes through in a timely fashion (yeah right) I wonder if the NBA players could use a similar line of defense to bust the lockout....



Other posts in this category