Pedals and my Rivendell Atlantis

I got an Atlantis not too long ago and love it!!!!! I have a road bike (about 2 yrs old Orbea Onix which I also love and don't want its' feelings to be hurt....) but I wanted a bike for other riding:errands, trails (VA Creeper, New River), trips - DH and I planning to do Pittsburgh to DC/Allegheny Passage etc. So many trips so little time!

I have been using SPD/clipless on my previous bikes for years, and happy with it, no problems. I use SPD because we do longer tours on the road bikes and like to walk around. On the Atlantis I got the MKS BMX pedals for the riding that I'm doing on it I did not want to be tied to cycling shoes all the time. I did 70 miles of the Creeper Trail and it was ok. My shoe did slip a time or two and it seemed like after my knee had the tiniest twinge, but nothing serious. I really did not think about my form during that ride and probably should have. I can't do cages or straps, they make me crazy. Tried them many years ago when I was resisted the clipless.

Next month I am going on a supported Woman Tour of Asheville, NC. So there will be hills. I imagine most people will bring road bikes, but I want to take the Atlantis. I think it will be fine, except I am worried about the hills and the pedals. Since it will be a hilly 5 days, I am nervous to tour that long on the BMX pedal. I've done supported tours before, but always with my SPD's. I would hate to be slipping of the pedals or get a knee ache etc. I know the SPD's work for me.

So I am thinking about changing out the pedals on my Orbea to the Atlantis for the trip. Was looking for any advice or experience on touring and your pedals. Thanks!!!!!

Changing pedals is easy. Use whatever makes the most sense for the ride. If you have the space you can even take both pairs of shoes and pedals (and pedal wrench) and swap.

Just don't try some new combo the day of the trip.

Sounds like a fun tour you're about to go on. Is it through Woman Tours?

What about Wellgos or pedals that are spd on one side and flat plaform on the other? That way you could clip in when you're climbing, but still have the flexibility of putting on your flip flops (or whatever) and riding on the flat side. I like spd's and mtn bike shoes for touring (what little I've done). I like being able to walk normally in my shoes. I just bought some of the Keen commuter sandals from TE (and they arrived today- but I can't try them because it's raining ). I digress.. use whatever is comfortable for you and what works best. I, too, think that bmx pedals wouldn't be a good idea for the 5 day tour, tho.

Or...take both sets like SadieKatie suggested.

well i know you said no straps- I assume you refer to PowerGrip straps and not just to the straps that come on cages?

.....but I have to recommend PowerGrip straps anyway- I have them on both my road bikes (one a Rivendell Rambouillet). I use the MKS Touring pedals- they are a bit wide and that's good when I'm wearing my big insulated hiking boots in the winter.

Without the straps, my rough tread running shoes and hiking shoes slip right off the pedal despite all the pointy teeth and rubber tread- as soon as the bottoms of my shoes get wet as in walking on damp grass or mud.

You can adjust the straps LOOSE- just enough so your shoe can't slip forward off the pedal, but loose enough to easily slip your foot on and off the pedal.

I keep my straps snug though- I like them that way and it keeps my feet from creeping forward on the pedals too much without my realizing and then having unexpected toe overlap on a wobbly steep hill.

The Atlantis is a great bike!

Not to mention gorgeous.

Thanks, all!

Lisa - I have tried cages, but not the Power Straps. I guess it would not be a huge invest. to try them..... I don't have the touring pedals though...will they attach?

Your bikes are beautiful!

TriGirl - Yes it is Woman Tours...my first. I have done lots of Backroads Tours with DH but I was going to do this with a friend and she changed her mind, but I didn't want to.

So I am going forward and really can't wait!

When I bike with DH we are mostly biking separately anyway...we've never mastered that togetherness thing. Our most important accessory on a bike trip is cell phone, "Where ARE you?", lol.

He's a strong rider but "lollygags" at stops, and I like to keep truckin'. I have been eyeing those Keens. Please let me know how you like them....I'm heading to REI on Friday just to have a look-see. (code for: I-will-buy-something-not-sure-what)

SadieKate - smacking forehead...I feel stupid. I can just take both sets and a wrench instead of fretting about one or the other. Since this is supported I can just stash the extra in my luggage. I love not having to decide!!!! Unbelievable I had not considered that!!

I think this is where Tater would chime in with a "well, duh!"